Have you ever stood in the formula aisle, staring at rows of cans, and felt your chest tighten a little? I remember that moment. Bright labels, words like “organic,” “sensitive,” and “non-GMO,” all shouting at once. It’s not just about picking a product—it’s about feeding your baby. That makes every choice feel huge.
So when parents ask, “Is Earth’s Best formula good?”, it’s not a casual question. It’s really about trust. You want to know if what you’re giving your baby is safe, if it supports growth, and if it’s gentle on tiny stomachs. You want the peace of mind that you’re doing right by your child.
That’s why this guide exists. I’ll break down what’s inside Earth’s Best, how it compares to other formulas, and what real parents (myself included) have experienced. Think of it as a mix of research, expert insight, and honest parenting stories—all in one place, so you don’t have to piece it together at 2 a.m.
Table of Contents
Overview: What Is Earth’s Best Formula?
Earth’s Best is one of the most well-known organic baby formulas in the U.S. The company started in the mid-1980s and built its name on simple, clean food. Parents often pick it because it uses fewer pesticides, no GMOs, and ingredients that feel closer to nature.
You’ll find a few main types:
- Organic Dairy Infant Formula – the standard version
- Sensitivity Formula – lower in lactose for easier digestion
- Soy-Based Formula – for babies who can’t have dairy
- Toddler Formula – for children over 12 months
What makes Earth’s Best stand out is its organic seal. Unlike some other brands, it avoids corn syrup solids as the main carb. Instead, it uses lactose, the same sugar found in breast milk. For many parents, this feels like a more “real” choice.
Nutrition & Ingredients Breakdown
So, what’s inside the can? The base is cow’s milk protein (or soy in the soy version). Energy comes from lactose. In the sensitivity type, some lactose is swapped out for other carbs to help babies who get gassy.
All formulas are USDA Organic and GMO-free. This means the cows aren’t given growth hormones, and the farms meet strict organic rules.
Extra nutrients include:
- DHA & ARA – fats that help brain and eye growth
- Iron – to prevent anemia, common in infants
- Prebiotics – support gut health and softer stools
Still, no formula is the same as breast milk. Earth’s Best does not have antibodies or live immune factors. The fat blend is also different. Some parents notice it mixes a little frothy, which can add to gas.
Safety & Quality Standards
Parents trust Earth’s Best because it meets USDA organic rules. These rules limit pesticides, synthetic fertilizers, and antibiotics in milk.
On top of that, the formula has to follow FDA nutrition and safety standards. There have been a few recalls over the years, mostly for packaging or label issues. But there have been no ongoing safety risks.
Keep in mind:
- Dairy versions have cow’s milk protein, which some babies can’t handle.
- Sensitivity formula is lower in lactose but still dairy-based.
- Soy formula skips dairy, but not all babies tolerate soy.
From my own experience, I tried the sensitivity version when my toddler had gas. It helped a little, but not fully. Each baby is different. Some thrive on Earth’s Best from day one, while others may need a switch.
Taste & Baby Acceptance
One of the first questions parents ask is: Will my baby drink it? Taste is tricky to measure, but parent feedback helps. Many say Earth’s Best has a mild, less sweet flavor. That’s because it skips corn syrup solids, which can taste sugary.
Some babies drink it with no problem. Others fuss at first, especially if they’re used to a sweeter formula. When I switched my toddler from a hospital-recommended brand, the first bottles were slow. But after a week, he adjusted and seemed fine.
Switching from breast milk can go either way. Some babies take it right away. Others spit up more or get gassy at first. Like with any formula, it depends on your baby’s system.
Types of Earth’s Best Formula Compared
Earth’s Best comes in a few main types:
- Organic Dairy Infant Formula – the standard, with lactose as the main carb
- Sensitivity Formula – lower in lactose for babies who get gassy
- Soy Formula – dairy-free, made with soy protein
- Toddler Formula – for kids over 12 months who still need extra nutrients
Quick Glance Table
| Formula Type | Best For | Key Difference |
| Organic Dairy Infant Formula | Most babies | Uses lactose, no corn syrup |
| Sensitivity Formula | Babies with mild lactose issues | Reduced lactose |
| Soy Formula | Dairy intolerance (not soy allergy) | Dairy-free, soy-based |
| Toddler Formula | Kids 12+ months | Made for older babies |
Pros and Cons (Honest Breakdown)
Here’s the good and the not-so-good:
Pros
- USDA Organic and GMO-free
- No corn syrup solids in most versions
- Easy to find in stores and online
- Includes DHA, ARA, iron, and prebiotics
Cons
- Costs more than mainstream brands
- Can mix frothy, which may add gas
- Taste may take time for some babies
- Sensitivity formula still has dairy
Parents who want an organic formula with simple ingredients, and babies who do fine with dairy or mild lactose changes.
How It Compares to Other Popular Formulas
Parents often weigh Earth’s Best against other big names:
- Similac Organic – Similar organic promise, but often sweeter due to carb choice.
- Enfamil NeuroPro – Not fully organic, but has extra brain-support nutrients and is often doctor-recommended.
- Kendamil Organic – A European formula, now in some U.S. stores, with whole milk and a creamier taste.
When Earth’s Best may be better:
- If you want certified organic and non-GMO assurance
- If you prefer lactose over corn syrup as the main carb
- If you want a formula easy to find at Target, Walmart, Amazon, or most grocery stores
Parent Reviews & Real-Life Experiences
If you read U.S. parenting forums or Amazon reviews, you’ll see mixed stories. Many parents love that Earth’s Best is organic, gentle, and easy to buy at Target or Walmart. Some say it feels good to give their baby a formula without corn syrup solids. Others notice softer stools and less spit-up compared to big brands.
On the flip side, a few parents report gas or babies refusing the taste. Some also say it can foam or clump when mixed, which makes feeding harder. Like all formulas, it depends on your baby.
From my own use, I tried the Sensitivity version when my toddler had tummy issues. The first bottles were rough—lots of fussing and slow drinking. But after a week, he adjusted and it became routine. I’ve also talked with parents whose babies never took to it, and they had to switch. That’s why I always remind parents: formula is trial and error.
Price & Availability
Earth’s Best is not the cheapest, but it’s not the priciest either. On average, it costs about $1.20–$1.35 per ounce. That’s higher than store brands but less than imports like Kendamil or HiPP.
You can find it almost everywhere:
- Big box stores like Target and Walmart
- Pharmacies like CVS and Walgreens
- Online at Amazon, often in bulk packs
Many parents save money with multipacks or subscription programs. If your baby drinks it daily, that can help with the monthly cost.
Who Should Consider Earth’s Best Formula?
Earth’s Best is a good choice if:
- You want certified organic, GMO-free ingredients
- You prefer formulas without corn syrup solids
- Your baby does well on cow’s milk protein or mild lactose changes
It may not be right if your baby has a true cow’s milk allergy, soy issues, or needs a hydrolyzed formula. In those cases, your pediatrician will suggest better options.
Final Verdict: Is Earth’s Best Formula Good?
For many families, yes. Earth’s Best is safe, reliable, and high quality. It’s organic, easy to find in the U.S., and trusted for decades. But no formula is perfect. Some babies thrive, while others need a switch.
At the end of the day, the best formula is the one your baby drinks, digests well, and grows on. Earth’s Best checks many boxes for parents who value clean ingredients and organic rules. Still, always watch how your baby responds.
FAQs: Is Earth’s Best Formula Good?
Is Earth’s Best formula good for newborns?
Yes. Earth’s Best Organic Infant Formula meets all FDA rules for newborns. Parents like it because it has an organic seal and simple ingredients.
Does Earth’s Best formula cause gas?
Some babies get gassy, especially when switching. Many adjust within a week. If gas keeps up, check with your pediatrician.
Is Earth’s Best formula better than Similac or Enfamil?
It depends on your baby. Earth’s Best is fully organic and uses lactose as the main carb. Similac and Enfamil use different blends.
Where can I buy Earth’s Best formula in the U.S.?
You can find it at Target, Walmart, CVS, and Amazon. Buying in bulk or with a subscription online may save money.
Who should not use Earth’s Best formula?
Babies with a cow’s milk allergy or soy sensitivity may not do well on it. In those cases, a hydrolyzed or specialty formula is better.
