Leaking between feeds? Or trying to build a freezer stash without being stuck to a pump? This guide—Boon Trove vs Haakaa—shows what makes these two silicone pumps different.
I’ve used both during cluster feeds, work calls, and sleepy night sessions. As a hands-on parent and gear tester, I’ll give you clear tips that work in real life. Let’s dive in.
Table of Contents
Boon Trove Breast Pump Review: A Hands-Free Helper for Busy Parents
The Boon Trove is a soft, wearable silicone pump. It catches milk without cords, noise, or tricky parts. It’s small, quiet, and fits right in your bra. If you want to save extra milk without stress, this pump makes it easy.
I tried the Boon Trove during my second breastfeeding journey. I already had a regular pump and a Haakaa. But I wondered—could something this small really work in real life? It did. And it surprised me in the best way.
What I Like
Here’s what stood out while using the Boon Trove:
- Truly hands-free – I slipped it into my nursing bra and kept moving. I folded laundry, made lunch, even held my toddler.
- Soft silicone – It felt gentle. It didn’t hurt or leave my skin sore, even after a long wear.
- Quiet and discreet – No noise. No one noticed it under my shirt while running errands.
- Easy to clean – Just a few parts. All dishwasher-safe. Cleaning was quick and simple.
- Great for letdown – It worked best while nursing or when I felt a letdown coming on.
Each feature made my day easier. It fit my routine and gave me comfort—both physical and mental.
What Could Be Better
No pump is perfect. Here’s what didn’t work as well for me:
- Small milk capacity – It holds less than a Haakaa or electric pump. If I had a big letdown, I had to empty it fast.
- Gentle suction – It’s more passive than active. It won’t replace a full pump session.
- No measurement lines – I had to guess how much I collected until I poured it out.
- No travel pouch – I tossed it in a zip bag when packing my diaper bag.
These aren’t dealbreakers. But they matter if you’re building a big stash or need to track ounces.
My Parenting Experience
I used the Boon Trove during the day. My baby would nurse on one side, and I’d catch milk on the other.
It also helped when I felt “touched out” and didn’t want to deal with tubes and flanges.
One time, I wore it during school pickup. My baby missed a feed, and I felt the pressure—literally. I slipped in the Boon, and by the time I got home, I had a couple ounces.
It gave me more freedom. No cords. No setup. Just relief when I needed it most.
Performance Overview
| Feature | Rating | Notes |
| Safety & Materials | 5/5 | Soft, BPA-free silicone; no irritation |
| Ease of Use | 4.5/5 | Simple and easy to use one-handed |
| Portability | 5/5 | Small and light—great for diaper bags |
| Cleaning & Maintenance | 4.5/5 | Few parts, all washable |
| Comfort & Fit | 5/5 | Gentle seal; no tugging or pain |
These scores reflect real use, not lab tests. I rated them based on comfort, ease, and how much they helped me during my day.
Who Should Buy It?
The Boon Trove is great for:
- New parents who want a soft, quiet milk catcher
- Parents with older kids who need to multitask
- Families always on the go
- Anyone with sore nipples who can’t use strong suction
- Parents who want to build a stash little by little
If you need to pump large volumes or count every ounce, it may not be your only pump. But if you just want a simple, low-stress way to collect milk, this is a great helper.
Final Thoughts
The Boon Trove isn’t here to replace your main pump. It’s made for the in-between moments—those times when you’re nursing, driving, or doing the dishes, and letdown sneaks in.
It helped me save milk I would have lost. And sometimes, that extra ounce made my whole day better.
If you want a soft, stress-free milk catcher that fits into your real life, the Boon Trove is a smart pick.
Haakaa Breast Pump Review: A Simple Tool That Just Works
If you’re breastfeeding and tired of leaking into bra pads, the Haakaa pump might be your new best friend.
It’s not fancy. No cords. No buttons. No noise. But it works. And it helps you save milk you’d normally lose.
I first used the Haakaa during the early, messy weeks with my first baby. I didn’t want to deal with flanges or wires. I just needed something simple. The Haakaa did the job.
What I Like
Here’s what I loved most about the Haakaa:
- Soft, one-piece design – No hard edges. No small parts. The silicone is food-grade and gentle on sore skin.
- Catches letdown – While nursing on one side, I’d pop it on the other. I often got 2–3 ounces without effort.
- Easy to clean – Just rinse or toss it in the dishwasher. No tubes. No hassle.
- Great for building a stash – I saved a lot of milk during those first few weeks.
- Quiet and discreet – I used it in the car, on Zoom calls, and even during bedtime stories.
Each feature saved me time, milk, and stress—things that were always in short supply.
What Could Be Better
It’s not perfect. Here’s what didn’t work as well:
- Easy to knock off – A few times, I bumped it and spilled milk everywhere.
- No measurement lines – I had to guess how much I’d collected.
- Gentle suction only – It doesn’t pull milk like an electric pump. It just collects what flows.
- No lid included – You’ll need to buy a stopper or cap if you want to store milk in it.
- Not great for low supply – If you’re trying to boost supply or fully empty, it’s not enough on its own.
These may not matter for everyone, but they’re good to know based on your goals.
My Parenting Experience
I used the Haakaa a lot in the first 6 months with both of my kids. My routine was simple: baby nursed on one side, and the Haakaa caught milk from the other.
Some days, I’d collect ounces without trying. Other days, I was just glad it kept my shirt dry.
One moment stands out. I had mastitis and didn’t want to set up my big pump. I used the Haakaa in the shower with a warm cloth. It didn’t fix everything—but it helped ease the pain.
When things felt out of control, the Haakaa gave me back a little bit of calm.
Performance Overview
| Feature | Rating | Notes |
| Safety & Materials | 5/5 | Soft, BPA-free, food-grade silicone |
| Ease of Use | 5/5 | Just squeeze, attach, and go |
| Portability | 5/5 | One piece, no wires—perfect for travel |
| Cleaning & Maintenance | 5/5 | Simple to rinse or toss in dishwasher |
| Comfort & Fit | 4/5 | Soft seal, but easy to knock off |
These ratings come from real use—not a lab.
Who Should Buy It?
The Haakaa is perfect for:
- New parents who want to catch milk during letdown
- Anyone with oversupply or strong letdown
- Parents who need a gentle option after birth
- People who hate cleaning pump parts
- Families on a budget (it’s way cheaper than electric pumps)
It’s not made to boost supply or replace full pump sessions. But as a backup or bonus tool? It’s amazing.
Final Thoughts
The Haakaa isn’t high-tech. It won’t empty your breasts or pump on its own. But that’s not the goal.
It’s simple. It’s quiet. And it saves milk that would otherwise soak a pad. If you want an easy way to build a stash—or just catch letdown while you nurse—the Haakaa is 100% worth it.
Sometimes, the simplest tool makes the biggest impact.
Detailed Comparison — Boon Trove vs Haakaa
I tested both the Boon Trove and Haakaa pumps during busy weeks filled with cluster feeds, skipped naps, and school runs. One gave me comfort on the go. The other helped me save milk during slow, sleepy mornings.
Here’s how they stack up—and which might fit your routine best.
Safety & Comfort — Boon Trove vs Haakaa
| Product | Safety Features | Comfort Factors |
| Boon Trove | BPA-free, food-grade silicone | Soft and wearable; gentle suction |
| Haakaa | BPA-free, food-grade silicone | One-piece; gentle on sore nipples |
Both are safe and soft. But the Boon Trove wins for comfort. It felt light, and I often forgot I was wearing it.
Rating:
Boon Trove: 9.5/10
Haakaa: 8.5/10
Ease of Use — Boon Trove vs Haakaa
| Product | Setup Experience | Adjustments Needed |
| Boon Trove | Just pop it in your bra | No setup—just position it |
| Haakaa | Squeeze and attach | Must stay still to avoid spills |
The Boon Trove was truly hands-free. I could move, cook, and play. The Haakaa worked—but only when I stayed still.
Rating:
Boon Trove: 9.5/10
Haakaa: 7.5/10
Durability & Maintenance — Boon Trove vs Haakaa
| Product | Materials | Cleaning Ease |
| Boon Trove | Soft silicone; holds shape | Few parts; dishwasher-safe |
| Haakaa | One-piece silicone | Rinse or top-rack dishwasher |
Both are easy to clean, which helps when you’re tired. The Boon Trove kept its shape better. The Haakaa felt softer but needed careful storage.
Rating:
Boon Trove: 9/10
Haakaa: 8.5/10
Portability & Size — Boon Trove vs Haakaa
| Product | Folded Size | Carrying Ease |
| Boon Trove | Small; fits in any bag | Light and worn inside your bra |
| Haakaa | Bulky shape | Light but harder to hide |
The Boon Trove was easier to wear out and about. I used it while driving, shopping, and walking. The Haakaa was less discreet and easier to knock off.
Rating:
Boon Trove: 9.5/10
Haakaa: 7.5/10
Value for Money — Boon Trove vs Haakaa
| Product | Price Range | Key Features |
| Boon Trove | Mid-range | Hands-free, wearable, discreet |
| Haakaa | Budget | Simple, works well, no extras |
The Haakaa gives great value if you’re just catching letdown. The Boon Trove costs more but makes daily life smoother.
Rating:
Boon Trove: 8.5/10
Haakaa: 9/10
Overall — Boon Trove vs Haakaa
| Product | Overall Score | Summary |
| Boon Trove | 9/10 | Best for comfort, movement, and multitasking |
| Haakaa | 8.5/10 | Best for saving milk at home on a budget |
Final Thoughts
Both pumps are smart tools that helped me in different ways.
If you’re always moving or caring for other kids, go with the Boon Trove. It fits your bra and lets you live life while saving milk.
If you’re mostly nursing at home and just want to catch milk while feeding, the Haakaa is a solid, budget-friendly choice.
FAQs — Boon Trove vs Haakaa
What’s the main difference between Boon Trove and Haakaa?
Boon Trove is hands-free and fits in your bra. Haakaa needs to be held or stays on only if you’re still.
Is Boon Trove better for multitasking?
Yes, the Boon Trove is great for parents on the move. It stays in place and collects milk while you’re active.
Can I use Haakaa while nursing?
Absolutely. The Haakaa works best when you nurse on one side and use it on the other to catch letdown.
Which one is easier to clean?
Both are simple to clean. Boon Trove has a few dishwasher-safe parts. Haakaa is one piece and rinses easily.
Which is more discreet in public?
Boon Trove is more discreet. It fits inside your bra and stays hidden, even during errands or meetings.
